FOLLOW US
Newsletter
Sneaker Fortress
  • Sneaker News
  • Popular Releases
  • Top 10
Step Into the Future of Sneaker Culture.
Nike Shop
Sneaker Fortress
No Result
View All Result
  • Nike Shop
  • Top 10
  • Air Jordans
  • Nike
  • adidas
  • ASICS
  • Converse
  • Crocs
  • New Balance
  • PUMA
  • Reebok
  • Vans
Home Air Jordans

10 Overrated Air Jordan Sneakers That Keep Selling Out

Even though they fly off shelves, these overrated Air Jordan sneakers might not be all they’re hyped up to be.

Jarrod Saunders by Jarrod Saunders
September 8, 2025
in Air Jordans, Trending
Overrated Air Jordan Sneakers

Image Credit: Sneaker Fortress

You’ve seen them everywhere: Air Jordans that vanish off shelves like they’re magical, yet when you look at them, you wonder why anyone’s losing their mind. Some hype trains make sneakers feel untouchable, even when they look like every other pair out there. Drake’s Certified Lover Boy Air Force 1s sold out in minutes, and plenty of Air Jordans do the same. People pay hundreds, chase the clout, and nod like these are must-haves, but scratch the surface and the appeal fades. These are the overrated Air Jordan sneakers everyone talks about, but few can explain why they matter.

Air Jordan 4 “Black Cat”

Black Cat Air Jordan 4
Image Credit: Sneaker Fortress

Air Jordan 4 “Black Cat” are dropping again this November, and apparently, everyone’s losing their minds… again. Yeah, it’s a nod to Michael Jordan, his stealthy moves, and bad luck for opponents, but, in all honesty, this is just a $225 all-black sneaker. The AJ4 is a classic silhouette, sure, a Tinker Hatfield original that changed the game in the ’80s, and we can all respect that, right? But the hype over ‘Black Cat’ are confusing. They look like super plain. Not terrible, not great, just another AJ4. Honestly, it’s the most overrated Jordan sneaker right now, and, yes, I’m fine standing alone on that deserted sneaker island.

Travis Scott x Fragment x Air Jordan 1 Low OG

Travis Scott x Fragment Air Jordan 1 Low
Image Credit: Jordan Brand

The Travis Scott x Air Jordan 1 Low Canary was fire, but most of the other colorways feel… ordinary. Take the upcoming 2025 Travis Scott x Fragment x Air Jordan 1 Low OG. It borrows from a 2021 sample Hiroshi teased, with a white leather upper, sail midsoles, and Military Blue trim. Yes, it has the reverse Swoosh everyone notices, but beyond that it’s just another AJ1. Plain, simple, predictable. And still, it will probably sell out in seconds when it drops in September. Sometimes hype makes the ordinary feel untouchable, and sneakerheads are happy to play along.

Air Jordan 3 “Lucky Shorts”

jordan 3 lucky shorts
Image Credit: Jordan Brand

The Air Jordan 3 “Lucky Shorts” drops as part of the 40th-anniversary celebration, celebrating Michael Jordan’s UNC days and his quirky superstition. The base is “Hydrogen Blue” and “Legend Blue,” nodding to the shorts that supposedly brought him luck, with extra touches like “Photon Dust,” “Summit White,” “Pure Platinum,” and “Sail” to modernize the look. But the reality? These are just AJ3s with a hint of baby blue. The colorway is fine, it’s clean, but the hype around these feels overblown. People are treating them like a must-have, when in truth they’re just another pair in the long AJ3 lineup.

Air Jordan 3 “Pure Money”

Air-Jordan-3-Retro-'Pure-Money'
Image Credit: Jordan Brand

The overrated Air Jordan 3 “Pure Money” is back, and hype is through the roof for a sneaker that’s mostly just plain. It’s set to drop in 2025 with subtle white Elephant Print on the toe and heel, paired with matching Elephant Print laces. Collectors were hoping for the scripted “Pure $” behind the heel tab, but that detail didn’t make the cut. The AJ3 silhouette itself is solid, but this release doesn’t add much beyond clean colors. Fans will rush for it anyway, paying top dollar for a shoe that’s hype more than innovation.

Air Jordan 1 Low OG “Chicago”

Air Jordan 1 Low OG "Chicago"
Image Credit: Jordan Brand

The Air Jordan 1 Low OG “Chicago” is back, but the hype feels unnecessary. The Chicago colorway has been on almost every silhouette countless times, so calling it a “must-have” now seems overblown. Collectors and casual fans alike already have multiple pairs, and the resale market has inflated the hype even further. The low-top version drops before the end of 2025, which gives you a chance to snag a pair without paying four figures on resale. The colorway still pops, but the frenzy surrounding it doesn’t match the sneaker itself. It’s classic, but the obsession is tired.

Air Jordan 11 “Rare Air”

michael jordan Air Jordan 11 Rare Air Colorway
Image Credit: Sneaker Fortress

The Air Jordan 11 has always been a sell-out sneaker, and the hype hasn’t slowed down in decades. The “Rare Air” release lands with the classic AJ11 formula: a white leather upper meets dark blue patent leather mudguard, a look as timeless as ever. Jordan text on the laces adds a nod to the legacy, and the “Jordan” lettering along the eyestays gives a small twist on a familiar silhouette. Beyond that, though, there isn’t much to separate this from past AJ11s. It’s a solid sneaker, but you can’t shake the feeling that Nike and Jordan Brand could have pushed this one further.

Air Jordan 12 “French Blue”

Air-Jordan-12-'French-Blue'
Image Credit: Jordan Brand

The Air Jordan 12 “French Blue” is getting more hype than it probably deserves. Back in 2003, Kobe Bryant rocked this colorway during his sneaker-free agency, and now in 2025, Nike and Jordan Brand are leaning on that history to sell excitement. The sneaker itself is white leather, blue accents, and the usual AJ12 silhouette. Yes, it has the classic look, but nothing to make your jaw drop. It’s meant as both a tribute to Kobe and a nod to the Jumpman legacy, but outside of that, it’s just plain Jane. People will camp out for it anyway, because hype doesn’t need substance.

Air Jordan 1 High “Cool Grey”

Air Jordan 1 High ‘Cool Grey’
Image Credit: Sneaker Fortress

Nike keeps trying to sell the overrated Air Jordan 1 as revolutionary, even though these kicks have been around since 1985 and basically started sneaker culture. The upcoming Air Jordan 1 High “Cool Grey” for Spring 2026 tries to mix it up with “Cool Grey” overlays on a clean white base, a black Swoosh, collar, and laces, plus “Game Royal” tongue tags and metallic gold accents. It’s neat, but nothing you haven’t seen before. The 1 has been hyped for decades, and the hype machine is still chugging. You can respect the color combos, but this feels more like a reminder that Jordan Brand knows how to sell nostalgia.

Jordan Jumpman Jack “Green Spark”

Travis Scott Jordan Jumpman Jack "Celtics" 
Image Credit: Sneaker Fortress

Travis Scott has a way of making every sneaker feel like a must-cop, even when it’s not. Take his Jordan Jumpman Jack colourway, spotted courtside during Game 2 of the 2025 NBA Finals. It’s slated for a 2026 release, but don’t expect anything groundbreaking. The silhouette is exactly the same as his previous drops, just dressed in green this time. Past colourways haven’t exactly been game changing either. But they’re gonna sell fast. Very fast.

Air Jordan 1 High OG “Sail/University Red”

Air Jordan 1 High OG "Sail/University Red"
Image Credit: Jordan Brand

The Air Jordan 1 High OG “Sail/University Red” is back, and the hype is already loud. Jordan Brand isn’t calling it an OG release or a collab, but those bright “University Red” overlays are standing out. Problem is, we’ve seen dozens of versions in this colorway before, so the excitement feels overblown. It’s the same silhouette, same basic design, just swapped colors. If you’ve been collecting 1s for years, this might not add anything new to your rotation. These are some serioiusly overrated Air Jordan sneakers.

RELATED: October Jordan Releases: Every Sneaker Fans Are Waiting On

Tags: Air Jordan
ShareTweetSend

About the Author: Jarrod Saunders

Jarrod Saunders is a Cape Town-based creative and founder of Fortress of Solitude, with over 20 years in film, gaming, and pop culture. He’s directed award-winning movies, built entertainment sites, and somehow still finds time to watch 500 films a year. Also: sneakerhead and part-time superhero.

Our favourites. Available now at Nike.com

This post includes references to products from some of our advertisers. We may earn compensation when you click on links to these products. The opinions and information provided on this site are the original editorial content of Sneaker Fortress.

Related Posts

Air Force 1 "Year of the Snake"
Nike Air Force 1

JohnnysKicks x Air Force 1 ‘Year of the Snake’ Slithers Into the Hottest CNY Sneaker Spot”

September 6, 2025
KAWS x Air Jordan 1 High
Air Jordan 1

John Trottier Reveals KAWS x Air Jordan 1 High 

July 8, 2025
House of Heat Union x Air Jordan 1 "Black/White-Shadow"
Air Jordan 1

The Union x Air Jordan 1 “Black/White-Shadow” House of Heat Concept Is Great

July 8, 2025
adidas Crazy IIInfinity "Bred" 
adidas

adidas Crazy IIInfinity “Bred” Is Coming In Hot

September 17, 2024
Nike Air Max 1 Sharimiki Bonsai
Nike Air Max

Miyagi-Do Would Love The Nike Air Max 1 “Sharimiki Bonsai”

September 3, 2024
Michael Jordan’s Favourite Air Jordan Sneakers, Ranked
Air Jordans

Michael Jordan’s 3 Favorite Air Jordans

November 1, 2024
Nike Killshot 2 "Phantom"
Nike

Nike Killshot 2 “Phantom” Is A Cheaper Travis Scott Air Jordan 1 “Black Phantom”

July 8, 2024
Sneaker Fortress

© 2025 Sneaker Fortress, a division of Fortress Entertainment. All Rights Reserved.

Company

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Work With Us
  • Advertise With Us
  • Sign Up For Our Newsletter
  • Publishing Principles
  • Ethics Policy
  • Ownership
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy & Site Disclaimer

Connect

Nike Shop
  • adidas
  • Converse
  • Air Jordans
    • Air Jordan 1
    • Air Jordan 2
    • Air Jordan 3
    • Air Jordan 4
    • Air Jordan 5
    • Air Jordan 6
    • Air Jordan 7
    • Air Jordan 8
    • Air Jordan 9
    • Air Jordan 10
    • Air Jordan 11
    • Air Jordan 12
    • Air Jordan 13
    • Air Jordan 14
    • Air Jordan 15
    • Air Jordan 16
    • Air Jordan 17
    • Air Jordan 18
    • Air Jordan 19
    • Air Jordan 21
    • Air Jordan 23
    • Air Jordan 39
  • New Balance
  • Nike
    • Nike Air Force 1
    • Nike Air Max
    • Nike Dunk
    • Nike Foamposite
    • Nike Kobe
  • PUMA
  • Reebok
  • Vans
  • Yeezy
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Web Stories

© 2025 Sneaker Fortress, a division of Fortress Entertainment. All Rights Reserved.